American Airlines must fix labour problems
Oct. 20, 2011, Dallas, Tx. - American Airlines is in bad need of an upgrade. The airline posted another loss on Wednesday — that's 14 out of the last 16 quarters.
Shares of parent AMR Corp. dropped 7.5 per cent, and they have fallen 66 per cent this year as investors worry that the company could be headed for bankruptcy protection.
AMR has nearly $5 billion in cash, more than many of its rivals and enough to avoid bankruptcy anytime soon.
But American needs to solve its labour problems, bring costs under control and provide better service to passengers if it is to pull out of a long financial nosedive that has resulted in the loss of more than $12 billion since 2001.
Here's what American must do, experts say:
— Control labour costs
AMR says its labour costs are $600 million a year more than other airlines — even more if pensions are included. Partly it's because other airlines dumped pension and other costs when they went through bankruptcy in the past decade.
American's unions hotly dispute AMR's figures and are seeking pay raises.
Management and the pilots' union recently stepped up talks and appear closer to a deal than ever — negotiations started in 2006. American wants pilots to fly more hours per month, much like they do
at competitor Southwest Airlines Co.
Deals with pilots, flight attendants and ground workers could save AMR $300 million to $400 million a year, analysts estimate. That wouldn't cover an expected $1.2 billion loss this year, but it would close the gap with competitors.
"Getting competitive about labour costs is critical for them,'' says Michael Derchin, an analyst with CRT Capital Group. "That would be a good start.''
— Improve service
American needs to improve its service to keep attracting passengers, who have many airlines to choose among. That means arriving on-time more often, which is especially important to business travellers. Its American Eagle subsidiary cancels a high number of flights.
"American used to be the industry leader,'' says Henry H. Harteveldt, a travel industry analyst with Atmosphere Research Group. "Now it's in the middle of the pack and falling.''
Harteveldt said American must upgrade seating in coach, add lie-flat beds in business class on international flights, and expand amenities such as in-flight Internet service and power outlets.
— Dump gas-guzzling planes
American has announced plans to upgrade its fleet by buying 460 planes from Airbus and Boeing. Chairman and CEO Gerard Arpey says the new planes will transform American by reducing fuel and
maintenance costs and giving customers a better ride, but those planes don't begin to arrive until 2013 and will be added gradually over several years.
American used to be a leader. It was the world's biggest airline, an innovative company whose ideas — from frequent-flier rewards to baggage fees — were loved or hated by passengers; but either way,
they were copied by other airlines.
Lately, American's creativity seems to have run dry. Investors have publicly challenged Arpey and other executives to come up with fresh thinking "beyond new flights to Helsinki,'' as one analyst put it.
Despite such restiveness, there are no clear outward signs that a change in leadership is imminent. "That's not going to happen. This management is in charge,'' said Ray Neidl, an analyst with Maxim
Group LLC, who only a month ago referred to management as "a caretaker of a deteriorating asset.''
But some analysts think a shake-up might not be far away.
While the airline industry has enjoyed strong revenue growth and other carriers have returned to profitability in the past two years, "unfortunately AMR sticks out as an airline still generating
losses,'' says Matthew Jacob, an analyst with ITG Investment Research. "I think it's something the board would probably consider.''
AMR reported Wednesday that it lost $162 million in the third quarter, as fuel costs wiped out a 9 per cent increase in revenue on higher fares. Fuel spending jumped 40 per cent, to $2.3 billion, easily topping wages and benefits as the biggest expense.
The company's loss of 48 cents per share was wider than analysts' forecast of 43 cents per share, according to FactSet. And it forecast fourth-quarter costs that were higher than some analysts had expected.